Common Situations
When You're Underwater or Have No Equity
When you'd net little or nothing from a traditional sale, other structures may work better. Learn about seller financing, lease-options, and loan assumptions.
If you owe more than your property is worth, a traditional sale doesn't work—there's no equity to cover the payoff. But being underwater doesn't mean you're trapped. This page maps the exit paths available and what each one trades.
Exit Paths Exist
Owing more than a property is worth—being "underwater"—does not mean you cannot sell. It means a traditional sale won't work: there's no equity to cover the payoff, and bringing cash to closing may not be feasible.
But exit paths exist that don't require equity. Short sales allow lenders to accept less than the full amount owed. Subject-to transactions let buyers take over payments regardless of the equity position. Deed-in-lieu transfers the property back to the lender without a full foreclosure process.
Each path has different requirements, timelines, and consequences. The question is not whether you can exit, but which exit's tradeoffs fit your situation.
What These Exits Trade
Credit Impact Varies by Exit Type
Different exits affect credit differently. Foreclosure typically drops scores by 100-160 points and remains on reports for seven years. Short sale impact is generally less severe—85-130 points—particularly if payments were current before the sale.
Recovery timelines differ too. After a short sale, new mortgage eligibility typically returns in 3-4 years. After foreclosure, the waiting period extends to 3-7 years depending on the loan type.
Subject-to creates a different dynamic: if the buyer continues making payments, the loan reports as current. No default, no foreclosure on the seller's record. But if the buyer stops paying, the seller's credit takes the full impact of whatever follows.
Credit is one tradeoff. Remaining debt is another.
Deficiency Exposure Varies
When a lender accepts less than owed—whether through short sale or foreclosure—the remaining balance is called a deficiency. In some states, lenders can pursue this balance through a deficiency judgment, seeking collection through wage garnishment or bank levies for 10-20 years.
But deficiency isn't guaranteed. Anti-deficiency states like California, Arizona, and Nevada prohibit pursuit of the shortfall on purchase money mortgages for primary residences. Even in states that allow deficiency, lenders frequently waive deficiency rights as part of short sale approval—the waiver speeds up the process and avoids collection costs.
The key: any deficiency waiver must appear explicitly in the short sale approval letter. Verbal assurances don't count.
Both credit and deficiency depend on timing—and you may have more time than you think.
Timeline Reality
Foreclosure timelines vary dramatically by state. In judicial foreclosure states—New York, New Jersey, Florida, Illinois—the process requires court proceedings and typically takes 18-24 months from first missed payment to sale. In non-judicial states—Texas, Georgia, California—the timeline compresses to 3-6 months.
This matters because time creates options. A seller in a judicial state who just received a notice of default has over a year to pursue alternatives: short sale negotiations, subject-to arrangements, loan modifications. A seller in a non-judicial state with an auction date in 60 days has far fewer options.
Knowing the actual timeline prevents decisions made in panic.
Time affects what you can pursue. But there's another factor most underwater sellers overlook.
The Cost of Waiting
Waiting for the market to recover has costs. When underwater, monthly payments contribute nothing to equity—every dollar goes to interest, taxes, and insurance while the principal balance remains higher than the property's value.
The math: a homeowner $50,000 underwater making $2,000 monthly payments may need 2-4 years of payments just to reach break-even, assuming no further market decline. That's $48,000-$96,000 in payments to get to zero.
Beyond the dollars: an underwater property limits mobility—can't relocate for a job without bringing cash to close or pursuing a distressed exit. The payments made during those years could have been invested elsewhere, rebuilding savings or credit in a new location.
Understanding the Options
Understanding Short Sales
Short sales require lender approval—the lender must agree to accept less than owed. The process typically takes 3-6 months from listing to close, with 60-120 days spent on lender approval negotiations.
For complete details on how short sales work, what lenders require for approval, and how to evaluate deficiency terms, see Short Sales and Deed-in-Lieu.
Understanding Subject-To
In a subject-to transaction, a buyer takes over payments while the loan remains in the seller's name. The deed transfers, but the promissory note—the personal obligation to repay—stays with the seller. Liability continues until the loan is paid off or formally assumed.
For complete details on how subject-to works, its risks and protections, and what to verify before agreeing, see Subject-To Transactions.
What This Means
Choosing Among Tradeoffs
Being underwater creates a choice among exit paths, not a trap. Each path trades different things.
Short sale requires lender cooperation. The lender must approve accepting less than owed, which takes time—typically 3-6 months. Credit impact is real but recoverable: most sellers can qualify for a new mortgage in 3-4 years. Deficiency may or may not be waived; the approval letter determines this.
Subject-to bypasses the lender entirely. A buyer takes over payments, and if they keep paying, the seller's credit stays intact. But the loan remains in the seller's name. If the buyer stops paying, the seller's credit—and potentially their personal liability—takes the hit. No lender approval needed, but ongoing risk accepted.
Deed-in-lieu is faster than short sale—60-90 days—but requires clear title. If there's a second mortgage or other liens, deed-in-lieu typically isn't available.
The question isn't "am I stuck?" The question is: Which set of tradeoffs—credit impact, liability exposure, timeline, and complexity—fits your situation?
For questions to ask before committing to any path, see Questions to Ask Before Signing.
Related Pages
Exit paths in detail:
Short Sales and Deed-in-Lieu — lender-approved exits
Subject-To Transactions — payment takeover without lender involvement
Before you decide:
Understand the risks:
Deficiency laws and foreclosure timelines vary by state. This information is educational, not legal advice.
We're investors, but we're also happy to answer questions →